Unexplained

Loch Ness Deception: The Absurd Film That Faked a Monster’s Roar

Loch Ness Monster (illustrative image)
Photo: Jeremy Thompson / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

The roar of a monstrous sound echoed across the dark waters of the loch, shattering the fragile façade of a carefully constructed lie. A furious crowd, whipped into a frenzy by manufactured hysteria, chased a writer and a mysterious French woman across the water. Just as the chaos reached its peak, a far older, undeniable truth emerged from the depths, rising to claim the final scene.

What a Whopper, released in 1961, was more than just a piece of British comedy; it was a sharp, satirical piece of cultural commentary disguised as a lark. Directed by Gilbert Gunn and featuring performances by Adam Faith, Sid James, and Carole Lesley, the film cleverly merged the mundane desperation of a struggling author with the enduring, almost mythical spectacle of the Loch Ness monster. It was a playful, yet biting, exploration of how quickly a story—whether true or entirely fabricated—can grip the public imagination.

The desperate pursuit of publicity

The entire premise of the film hinged upon the desperate plight of a writer named Tony Blake. He found himself in a precarious position, having penned a book that had been summarily rejected by the publishers. To overcome this professional setback, he concocted a scheme: faking a sighting of the legendary Loch Ness creature. His ultimate goal was to use this manufactured sensationalism to promote his unloved literary work.

Blake embarked on this elaborate ruse, journeying north to Scotland to continue his deception. The initial stage of his fabrication took place elsewhere, with Tony and his associate, Vernon, first documenting their phony monster in the Serpentine. The duo then proceeded to Scotland in a truly peculiar conveyance—a second-hand Rolls-Royce hearse—setting the stage for a journey steeped in theatrical absurdity and impending chaos.

The elaborate machinery of deceit

The attempt at deception quickly grew into a complex, shambolic affair, involving multiple layers of conspiratorial oddity. Along the way, the pair picked up Marie, a hitchhiker from France, adding another layer of unpredictable element to their travels. Furthermore, the inn landlord, Harry Sutton, provided a strange piece of supporting detail, discreetly hiding poached salmon within his establishment.

The true engineering of the monstrous encounter, however, was the work of Vernon. He secretly fitted a speaker into the narrative, designed specifically to broadcast guttural, monstrous roars. This auditory manipulation proved remarkably effective, convincing the local populace that they were witnessing a genuine, terrifying phenomenon.

When the laughs fade

The initial surge of enthusiasm among the locals was based almost entirely on the manufactured sounds, but the trick began to unravel when the physical evidence failed to materialize. The crowd’s excitement began to visibly diminish once Tony Blake could not produce the promised photographic proof of the beast.

The situation rapidly devolved from a shared moment of wonder into a ridiculous, localized farce. In a bizarre twist, the locals, finding themselves in a world of manufactured monster sightings, began to compete, attempting to attract business by creating their own fake versions of the creature. This escalating absurdity led to a frenzied chase, as an angry mob pursued both Tony and Marie across the sprawling expanse of the loch.

A lasting echo of the myth

The ultimate conclusion of the film offered a powerful commentary on the nature of belief versus reality. Just as the comedic chase reached its fever pitch, the carefully managed performance was overwhelmed by the undeniable presence of the actual Loch Ness creature, rising from the deep water.

The foundations of this cinematic mischief were laid years before the film was made, tracing back to the original story written by Jeremy Lloyd in the late 1950s. Lloyd had pitched his ideas to the studio chief, Earl St John, and the project was later expanded upon by Trevor Peacock, who contributed story ideas and made an uncredited appearance. Terry Nation’s resulting screenplay displayed both strengths and weaknesses, but the film’s pairing with Pit of Darkness gave it a peculiar, dark edge. Ultimately, the film asks whether the wildest stories are the ones we invent, or the ones that truly rise from the depths. After all, in the end, “the laughs are as elusive as Nessie.” — The Radio Times Guide to Films.

Background: Wikipedia

The Daily Ungrid

Five stories you can’t ignore, every morning at 7.

Join 412,000 readers. Free, and one tap to leave.

More from Ungrid Now