The glowing screen illuminated the late-night glow of the internet, promising a small financial reward for mundane activities. Members were being invited to participate in a revolutionary new system, a digital scheme where simply browsing the web could generate income. The promise was simple, yet seductive: “Get Paid to Surf the Web.” This burgeoning platform represented a radical shift in how online commerce and user engagement were conceived.
This ambitious enterprise, AllAdvantage, was positioned as the world’s first “infomediary.” It was a remarkable experiment in early digital economics, fundamentally altering the relationship between advertisers, online traffic, and the consumer. Instead of merely viewing ads, members were compensated directly from advertising revenue generated by their own online viewing habits.
The rise of the click economy
The concept was not entirely new, having been initially suggested by John Hagel, III, and Marc Singer in NetWorth. However, AllAdvantage was one of the first mass market implementations to bring this idea to life. Launched on March 31, 1999, the company quickly garnered massive traction, driven by the immediate appeal of earning money just by using the internet. The founders, including Jim Jorgensen, Johannes Pohle, Carl Anderson, and Oliver Brock, rapidly scaled the operation.
Its popularity was staggering; within just eighteen months, the company had swelled to a membership base exceeding ten million individuals. By the close of 1999, the company boasted over four million registered members across a vast network spanning 240 countries worldwide. This rapid growth propelled AllAdvantage.com into the top twenty of traffic indices, demonstrating an unprecedented level of consumer adoption for the infomediary model.
The dark side of digital revenue
Despite the incredible growth and the promise of revenue sharing, the company faced immediate practical hurdles that complicated its flawless façade. Early in its run, AllAdvantage faced significant criticism regarding its inability to effectively stop member spamming when users referred others. This issue raised immediate questions about the integrity of the referral system and the authenticity of the revenue generated.
The technology underpinning this entire system was built upon early desktop user tracking and ad targeting software known as Viewbar. While Viewbar allowed for the sophisticated tracking necessary for the infomediary model, this technology also formed the foundational basis for what would later become the contentious industries of adware and spyware. The delicate line between compensated viewing and intrusive tracking was constantly being tested.
Navigating legal and financial storms
Recognising the volatile nature of its business model, AllAdvantage took pioneering steps in corporate governance and legal compliance. The company appointed the world’s first corporate Chief Privacy Officer in August 1999, with privacy lawyer Ray Everett-Church taking on the crucial role. This move demonstrated an early, proactive acknowledgement of the privacy implications inherent in tracking user behaviour for advertising revenue.
The company’s success also garnered attention from legislators; executives became involved in anti-spam legislative proposals, including a US House bill. As the dot-com bubble began to burst and the mid-2000 recession took hold, the financial tides turned sharply against the company. IPO plans, which had been underwritten by Frank Quattrone of Credit Suisse First Boston, were eventually cancelled, signalling the end of its initial trajectory.
Survival and the lasting impact
The decline was not immediate, however. In a final attempt to secure new revenue streams, AllAdvantage broadened its offerings to include sweepstakes. Yet, the structural pressures were too great, leading the company to finally halt all consumer-facing operations in February 2001. Despite the closure, the company had successfully paid out more than $160 million to its members, cementing its status as a monumental, if flawed, early digital venture.
The eventual fate of the original entity did not mean the end of the concept. The founders later successfully reincarnated the business, establishing AGLOCO on November 20, 2006. Even before the collapse, the company had mastered the art of organic growth, successfully adapting the viral marketing concept, which Steve Jurvetson cited as a prime example in May 2000.
AllAdvantage remains a fascinating case study in the rapid, often chaotic, evolution of the internet economy. It pioneered the mass-market infomediary model, laying groundwork for modern digital advertising and consumer data practices. It stands as a stark reminder of the incredible potential—and the inherent risks—when the promise of digital wealth meets the reality of spam and economic downturns. The dream of earning money simply by watching the screen was real, but the price of that convenience proved to be far more complex than any member had imagined.
Background: Wikipedia









